Teaching Multicultural StudentsTips, Expert Advice, and Resources for Building Inclusion in the Classroom
Long hailed as a melting pot of cultures, America is home to millions of immigrants – whether their ancestors sailed across on the Mayflower or they moved to the country last week. Research by the National Center for Educational Statistics found that one-third of U.S. students are considered racial or ethnic minorities, a number that is set to increase to more than half by 2050. In this changing educational landscape, teachers are challenged with creating inclusive classrooms where students of all backgrounds feel represented and welcomed. The following guide explores how teachers can build inclusive multicultural learning environments.
Shilpa Bhouraskar is the founder of the education platform YesCourse. Designed to offer various online courses to students worldwide, since 2012, YesCourse has reached across global cultures, welcoming more than 10,000 students in over 74 countries. We asked Ms. Bhouraskar for her insights into classrooms that embrace multiculturalism.
Quiz for Teachers: How Well Do You Know Your Students?
For teachers with a classroom full of students of different backgrounds, the responsibility to connect with them goes beyond simply knowing where they’re from, or what their favorite subjects are. These teachers must strive to understand their students in a more holistic way, incorporating their cultural traditions into lessons and activities, so students feel understood, comfortable, and focused on learning. The following quiz helps teachers see how well they know their students and their cultural backgrounds.
Question 01I’ve met and formed a relationship with the parents of __
Question 02I make sure that my English-learning students ______.
Question 03I’m ________ aware of how my students fit into the federally-defined student subgroups.
Question 04For _____ of my students, I’m aware of their family structure, such as how many siblings they have and who their guardians are.
Question 05I’ve reviewed the demographic information about _______ of my students provided by the school office.
Question 06I express curiosity and interest in the cultural traditions of my students _____.
Question 07I make an effort in classroom activities to get my students to learn about each other’s different backgrounds _______.
Question 08My opinion on using lesson plans and books that teach about different cultures and ethnic groups is that ______.
Well done! You’ve taken the time to truly learn about your students and their lives. Building bonds and being inquisitive about each student ensures you know how to best incorporate their many different backgrounds and educational needs.Reset
Finding a Place for Culture in the Classroom
What is Culture?
Culture is a broad term, and one that is not easily summed up. In her book Culture Learning: The Fifth Dimension on the Language Classroom, author Louise Damen defined culture as the “learned and shared human patterns or models for living; day-to-day living patterns [that] pervade all aspects of human social interaction. Culture is mankind’s primary adaptive mechanism.” Individuals from varied nationalities, ethnicities, and races all bring cultural traditions to their interactions, and it’s up to teachers to recognize, celebrate and share these different perspectives. The following graphic displays some of the many ways that culture affects learning, both inside and outside the classroom:
Students are taught to process and understand ideas and information in different ways based on their cultural upbringings, meaning teachers may need to adapt lesson plans for multicultural classrooms.
How students treat authority figures, and what they expect from them, differs across cultures. While American children tend to be more informal, other cultures may have very formal structures for student-teacher relationships.
A complex blend of factors influences how students engage in the classroom. Students from impoverished backgrounds may struggle to focus and participate, and English-language learners may be less likely to speak up in class.
Cultural responses to conflict vary significantly, and it’s vital for teachers to be aware of these differences so they can mediate effectively. Some students are taught to avoid conflict at all costs, while other cultures see conflict as a positive and constructive exercise.
Given the same set of information about a problem, students from different cultural backgrounds are likely to suggest a wide array of solutions. A teacher’s job is to validate a range of approaches and help students understand there are multiple ways to solve a problem.
Food & Diet
Studies have shown that malnourished children struggle to remain focused and to retain information, so they are more likely to fall behind. Different family structures and socioeconomic factors can influence the nutrition students receive at home.
Socioeconomic status can influence school performance in many ways. For instance, some children may not be able to afford proper school supplies, causing them to struggle with homework assignments because they don’t have the right tools.
If a child is the only English speaker in their family, getting help from their parents or siblings on school assignments may not be possible. Some students may also have extra duties at home to help their parents communicate with others, taking time from their studies.
Family Structure & Values
Students come from all different types of households, from single-parent families to multi-generational homes to parents of the same gender. Family structure and values can influence how students see themselves, interact with others and their attitudes towards school.
Whether adhering to specific duties or rules set forth by their religion, or missing class because of a religious ritual, students from religious backgrounds that are less common in U.S. culture may have trouble balancing different priorities.
Different ethnicities and races have specific ideas about education and how to learn, some of which may clash with American ideas of classroom behavior or learning techniques.
In addition to cultural differences, students with physical or learning disabilities face an added obstacle to their learning. Students with family members who have disabilities may have different perspectives of education or less assistance with homework.
What is Multicultural Education?
Multicultural education is not a task to be done or even an end goal to be accomplished. Instead, it is an approach to education that aims to include all students, promote learning of other cultures, and teach healthy social skills in a multicultural setting. “It is the present and future of education,” according to Shilpa Bhouraskar, who runs a business offering online courses to students worldwide. “Multicultural classrooms are a melting pot of learning,” she says. “Rather than a passive, one-way flow of learning from teacher to student, there is a brainstorming of ideas, stories, and experiences that enrich the educational experience in ways that are impossible in monocultural classes.”
Classroom Resources for Multicultural Education
Using different activities and games in multicultural classrooms is an excellent way to foster inclusivity and encourage students to share their heritage. It’s also a beneficial way for teachers to involve students in different styles of study to immerse them in their learning. Sharing about oneself within the confines of an activity is often much easier than being asked open-ended questions and put “on the spot.” These activities can then provide a safe space for dialogue and serve as an entryway into more in-depth interactions. The following section outlines some examples of activities and games appropriate for different age groups.
|Elementary School||Secondary School|
Digital Holiday Field Trip Grades 1-5
Take a virtual field trip to different students’ places of origin, on days when their country or culture is celebrating a holiday unique to them.
Immigration Stories Middle or high school
Use Ellis Island’s interactive online tour to learn about different cultures that immigrated to America. Expand the activity by allowing students to share their unique families’ immigration stories.
Games Around the World Grades 1-5
Use the start of each lesson to learn about playground games from different cultures.
Ethnicity Exercise Middle or high school
Students discuss their ethnic backgrounds and share three unique things about their culture (food, holidays, celebrations, etc.).
The Name Game Grades 3-5
Students tell stories about what their names mean in their cultures and how they were chosen.
Writing Poetry High school
Students write poems that describe their identity, and then peer review in small groups.
Share a Meal Grades 3-5
Students (and their parents, if possible) bring in a dish their culture is known for and share it with their classmates.
‘Who Said It?’ Quiz High school
Teams compete to see who can identify the most quotes from historical leaders of inclusion movements (Gandhi, Martin Luther King, etc.).
Support and Resources for Teachers
Educating the future generation is a challenging job on its own, but for educators committed to culturally responsive teaching, the task can feel overwhelming at times. Fortunately, they don’t have to go it alone—there are numerous resources both within schools and online. Some of the top places that teachers can turn to for support include:
School counselors typically work one-on-one with students and gain a fuller understanding of a child’s background and home life. They can help teachers understand challenges that your students are facing outside of the classroom that can be affecting their learning.
Principals can be the driving force to help teachers enact change, engage parents, and set up meetings or events to encourage inclusive behaviors. They can be key leaders to implement multicultural learning strategies school-wide.
This professional association provides resources and hosts an annual conference for teachers striving for social justice and equity in their classrooms.
Operating at the University of Southern California, this group conducts research about best practices in multicultural teaching and shares its findings regularly.
CREDE offers research, curriculum development tips, videos, and resources for teachers of diverse classrooms.
An excellent resource for teachers who have students struggling against poverty.
Top 10 Books for Multicultural Learning
Reading aloud is an important teaching tool no matter the classroom, and books featuring children from different cultures can play a vital role in bringing all students together. Teachers can set the stage by reading aloud during class, or by having students take turns. For independent reading, students can be encouraged to choose books that allow them to step outside their culture. Below are some good examples of books that explore themes across varied cultures.
|Children’s Books||Young Adult Books|
A young girl from Mexico flees to California during the Depression and rises above difficult circumstances.
Tea with Milk
May leads a completely different life in America than she did in Japan. When her family moves back to Japan, she struggles to feel at home.
Under the Sunday Tree
A collection of 20 poems about Bahamian life for grades 3-6.
They Had a Dream
The Civil Rights Struggle – Provides biographies on four influential leaders of the civil rights movement.
Where the Flame Trees Bloom
Author Alma Flor Ada shares 11 true stories of her childhood in Cuba, told from the eyes of a child.
Windows Into My World
Collection of more than 50 short stories from Latino youth on growing up in America.
The Magic Paintbrush
A fantastical tale of a magic paintbrush that carries Steve from his life in San Francisco’s Chinatown to a lively world filled with adventure.
The Color Purple
This Pulitzer Prize-winning novel tells the struggles of African-American women in rural Georgia in the 1930s.
The Mockingbird’s Manual
Learning of her ability to speak to birds, a Navajo girl explores ways of communicating and learning, and shares them with her people.
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
Motivated by his goal to become a cartoonist, Junior leaves the Indian Reservation to attend an all-white high school in a nearby farming town.
The Name Jar
When Unhei moves to America from Korea, she’s convinced she’ll need a new name her classmates can pronounce, but her new friends have other ideas.
Best Ramadan Ever
Almira learns how to deal with temptation during the Holy Month while also trying to fit in to America.
The Sandwich Swap
Best friends Salma and Lily eat sandwiches at school every day, but Salma eats hummus and Lily eats peanut butter. Together, they work to overcome their differences.
Leela looks to Ghandi for hope for social and political change in 1940s India.
Last Stop on Market Street
As CJ and his grandmother ride the bus, he starts wondering about the differences between his life and those of his classmates.
Under the Moonlit Sky
Esha travels to India and learns about being a Sikh after her father passes away.
Brown Girl Dreaming
A collection of poems that share a glimpse into the life of an African-American girl growing up in New Orleans and New York in the 1960s and 70s.
Muslims Around the World Today
Traces the diversity of Muslims worldwide and introduces students to their beliefs and practices.
A Japanese man immigrates to America and then moves back to Japan, guided by his love for both countries.
Children of War
Voices of Iraqi Refugees – Includes 20 stories from children growing up during the Iraq War.
Teacher Resources for ESL Students & Families
ESL, an acronym for English as a Second Language, is a study program for students who are nonnative English speakers. Ideally, ESL teachers can use their students’ cultural traditions and customs to help them learn about one another and find topics of conversation in English, although it will take creativity and forethought to effectively incorporate the experiences of students from many different cultural backgrounds. Some of the best resources for multicultural integration and ESL learning are given below.
This nonprofit provides resources and a community for English teachers throughout the world.
Between Worlds: Access to Second Language Acquisition
This book helps K-12 teachers adopt proven and successful measures for teaching ESL.
Building Classroom Community Through Art
This lesson plan from the J. Paul Getty Museum shows teachers how using art can bring students from different cultures together in ESL classes.
Cambridge English Webinars
Cambridge English provides a series of webinars throughout the year aimed at ESL teachers.
ELL Starter Kit
Colorin Colorado provides this helpful tool for ESL teachers to help them monitor how students are progressing in language skills.
English Language Learners, Day by Day, K-6
Author Christina Celic wrote this book drawing on her years of experience teaching ESL in elementary classrooms, both inside and outside the United States.
This site provides lesson plans, worksheets, quizzes, and forums where ESL teachers can connect.
For Parents & Guardians:
Strengthening Multicultural Education
Parents, guardians and other family members are a crucial component in educating the future generation. They serve as role models, advocates for their children, and links between their children and society as a whole. As active participants in their children’s learning, they can help ease the tension, confusion, or frustration that may arise when children are trying to navigate cultural and language differences. The following section highlights some of the ways parents, guardians and other family members can help their children receive the best education possible.
Attend multicultural sessions at school
Many schools offer sessions at the beginning of the school year to provide parents and guardians with tools for incorporating multiculturalism into home life. Take advantage of these sessions and meet other students’ families.
Take advantage of resources
Whether it’s the library at your child’s school or your city’s public library, countless resources – offered as books, videos, audio recordings, or lectures – are available to help learn about common topics in multicultural learning.
Sign up for “anti-bias alerts”
Popular culture has an enormous effect on children, but it isn’t always constructive. Numerous watchdog agencies exist to help parents be aware of television, film, or music content that is biased against cultures, so they may protect their children from it.
Spend time with the parents of your child’s classmates
One of the best ways to learn about other cultures is to spend time with the parents of your child’s classmates. Take turns preparing traditional dinners from your cultures or schedule a playdate.
Attend multicultural events
No matter the size of your city, chances are there are events celebrating other cultures. Check the calendar and find a family-friendly outing to learn about another culture or celebrate your own.
Learn more about your own heritage
America is commonly referred to as a melting pot because of the many citizens who trace their heritage to other countries. Take the time to learn more about your own roots and culture and share this with your children.
Promoting Inclusion: Solutions to Common Challenges
A classroom attuned to the individual histories and backgrounds of its students is best positioned to be an inviting and stimulating space for all students. Unfortunately, there are still many that fail to embrace and educate students on the beauty of difference. Some of the most common problems of non-inclusive classroom environments along with their solutions are listed below.
Bullying presents an increased risk in classrooms where students aren’t properly educated about different cultures.
Help students understand that classmates from other places aren’t weird or bad, only different, to help remove motivations that lead to bullying.
Cliques often exclude students from other cultures, as students don’t have the tools to interact with children who aren’t like them.
Ensure classroom activities are inclusive and designed to engage students with each other, to build friendship and familiarity.
Refraining from talking about culture means students remain ignorant of how their classmates learn and interact with the world.
Make sure lesson plans focus on the cultures and histories of all students in the classroom, not only those from majority groups.
Teachers who don’t take time to get to know their students’ backgrounds often set a negative precedent for student engagement.
Commit to speaking to all students on a regular basis, to send the message that interacting and learning about one another is important.
When teachers fail to discourage behavior that stems from stereotypes or misconceptions, it can foster bias against students of certain cultural backgrounds.
Teachers should be aware of preconceived ideas about the students in the classroom to guard against biased talk on the part of other students.
Spotlight: Advice for Teaching English Abroad
According to a recent report on international education, the number of international schools has risen by 153 percent in the last 12 years, with more than 529,000 qualified teachers expected to be employed overseas by 2022. Teachers who want to be truly immersed in multicultural classrooms are drawn to these positions, which often pay similar salaries as positions in America. Some of the top tips for succeeding in an international school system include:
Appropriate attire varies dramatically across cultures, and dressing too informally could be a sign of disrespect or show a lack of awareness about how teachers should present themselves.DO learn how to manage your classroom early on
Different cultures manage classroom behavior in different ways, so observe native teachers and learn about their practices of discipline.DO understand the country’s learning style
School children in America are taught to be engaged, energetic students, but other cultures train students to be quiet listeners. Just because all students aren’t raising their hands doesn’t mean they aren’t learning
Whether for praise or discipline, this is a decidedly American teaching habit and should be avoided in most international classrooms. Instead, encourage inclusive behaviors.DON’T neglect to monitor student progress
New teachers may feel like they are struggling, so it’s important to track how your students are doing to help remind you that they—and you—are making progress.DON’T forget to make inclusive learning fun
While it’s important to make sure students feel represented and known, it’s also important to make sure there are fun activities that help students naturally engage with each other without feeling like it’s an assignment.
Q & A: Advice from a Multiculturalism Expert
How does creating an inclusive classroom lead to better learning for all students?
Every topic discussed gets a unique flavor from the experiences of every student who contributes, based on their individual culture and background. Recently, in one of our classes we were discussing how to write a friendly, open email. It was fascinating to see how students from across the world tweaked the message differently based on cultural aspects of what friendly, open communication means to them. This type of discussion and input would have been impossible in a monocultural class.
What are some teacher behaviors that could encourage (and discourage) multiculturalism?
The first step for any teacher is being aware at all times that they are addressing a classroom spanning languages and culture. Everything they say, the examples they give, the issues they address, the opinions they express, and the stories they share should keep a higher perspective to avoid issues of prejudice in religion, culture and social structure. Self-awareness is a huge factor, as is being able to create a space where students feel their opinions are valid and accepted, and that there is no right or wrong answer. Experiencing the freedom to say things without fear, ridicule or judgment encourages the most interactive and enriching learning experiences for everyone.
What are the factors to consider when trying to create an inclusive classroom?
The main factor is creating an environment where open, honest conversation is possible. I also strongly believe in giving my students the freedom and control, rather than me controlling and monitoring what they should and should not say or do. If we trust and let students be within a multicultural room, they eventually tap into their humane side and find ways to understand each other. They still have their differences, but there is a growing sense of acceptance. Cultural barriers cease to exist and people can look beyond to focus on a common goal of learning.
Additional Resources for Teachers
Association for Multicultural Science Education
AMSE promotes science education within culturally diverse classrooms. The group provides a newsletter and hosts an annual conference.
International Multicultural Institute
More than 50,000 people have attended the IMCI’s annual conferences and workshops in recent years to work on developing inclusive educational institutions.
National Association on Bilingual Education
NABE advocates for teachers in bilingual education, and also offers an annual conference and series of publications.
National Education Association
The NEA devotes a section of its website to sharing resources for handling diversity and multicultural issues within classrooms.
New York Collective of Radical Educators
NYCoRE organizes multicultural events and conferences to encourage inclusivity even after the school bell rings.
The Importance of Multicultural Education
This academic paper by Geneva Gay makes the case for the critical role multicultural awareness and education plays in academic success and inclusivity.